When a Guest Asks for a Discount: How to Say No Without Saying No
A guest says, “Can you give me a discount?” or “Do you have something cheaper?”Behavioral Economics Insight: Anchoring, Loss Aversion, Fairness Bias, Reciprocity
It happens often — especially in boutique hotels and restaurants:
“Is that the best price you can do?”
“Can you do something better for me?”
And most staff freeze.
They either say “Sorry, no” (which sounds cold), or they run to a manager, creating a pattern of negotiation.
The truth? When guests ask for discounts, they’re not just being cheap. They’re often testing your value confidence — and your staff’s reaction decides whether they feel respected or dismissed.
Here’s what your staff must understand:
Behavioral economics shows that price perception is emotional. People don’t hate paying — they hate feeling like they overpaid or were treated unfairly. And once they feel ignored or rejected, they associate negative emotion with the whole experience.
What to do instead:
Your staff should redirect the conversation to highlight value, not cost — while offering a feeling of gain without lowering the price.
Example:
“We don’t offer discounts, but I’ll make sure you get the table with the best view — and we can bring out a complimentary starter if you’re celebrating something.”
Or:
“That price includes access to our lounge and complimentary breakfast — many guests say the full experience is what makes their stay worth it.”
Why this works:
- Reciprocity Bias – Offering a small bonus makes the guest feel like they got more than expected, triggering goodwill.
- Anchoring – Reminding them what’s included shifts the mental anchor from price to value.
- Fairness Framing – Saying “we offer the same pricing for everyone” emphasizes equality, not rejection.
What to avoid:
❌ Never say “It’s not my job” or “I can’t do anything.”
❌ Don’t argue or try to “convince” them logically — price is emotional.
❌ Don’t automatically involve a manager — it undermines staff authority.
How to train your team:
✅ Give them 2–3 ready phrases to reframe the value (e.g., what’s included, why it’s popular, what’s unique).
✅ Teach them to offer “soft bonuses” (a better seat, priority service, personal attention) as emotional compensation.
✅ Let them practice “discount deflection” using roleplays with difficult customers.
Bonus Behavioral Trick:
Place higher-priced options near your standard offerings (menu, room categories) so the regular price feels like a “smart deal.”
This leverages the Contrast Effect — suddenly, what seemed expensive feels reasonable.
BOTTOM LINE:
Saying no to discounts doesn’t mean being rigid. It means being smart, empathetic, and confident. When your staff learns how to make guests feel rewarded without cutting the price, they’ll win loyalty — and protect your margins.
Case Study 1: Soho House (Global)
Situation: Soho House is a private members-only hotel and club known for exclusivity and creativity. Many prospective members have tried to negotiate lower membership fees or room rates — especially during off-seasons.
What they did:
They never offer discounts — but they increase perceived access and emotional reward. For example:
- Offering early access to new Houses (hotels)
- Priority invites to exclusive events
- Complimentary welcome drinks or personalized upgrades
Staff are trained to say:
“We don’t do pricing tiers — but if you join today, I’ll add you to the private launch event guest list.”
Why it works:
- Fairness Principle – Everyone pays the same = status preservation.
- Reciprocity & Exclusivity – Guests feel they’re getting something others can’t.
- Endowment Effect – Once someone imagines themselves inside, they’re less likely to walk away.
Result:
High membership retention and growing waitlists — without diluting the brand by offering discounts.
Case Study 2: Nobu Restaurants (Global)
Situation: Nobu offers a luxury Japanese dining experience at a premium price. Guests often question high menu prices — especially for dishes like black cod ($40–$50+).
What they did:
Instead of discounting, Nobu staff are trained to romanticize the food and the story behind it. For example:
“The black cod is marinated for 72 hours — it’s our signature, created by Chef Nobu himself and known around the world.”
They anchor price to craftsmanship and let guests feel part of something elite.
Why it works:
- Value Framing – Guests focus on technique, not cost.
- Social Proof – “Signature dish” implies it’s a must-try.
- Status Signaling – Guests want to be seen eating something this premium.
Result:
Nobu maintains full pricing — with guests bragging, not complaining.
Case Study 3: Aman Resorts (Luxury Hotels Worldwide)
Situation: Aman is one of the world’s most expensive hotel chains, with rooms starting at $1000+/night. Guests sometimes inquire about off-season or “special” pricing.
What they did:
Aman never discounts. Instead, they add invisible upgrades:
- Extended check-out
- Private butler welcome
- Spa access or room enhancements
Staff are trained to say:
“We don’t discount our rates, but we do customize your experience. Let me add a few things that will make it more personal.”
Why it works:
- Loss Aversion – Guests don’t want to lose the extra care.
- Framing – The guest still feels like they “won” something.
- Luxury Norm Enforcement – Discounts would damage brand equity.
Result:
Aman remains one of the most profitable hotel groups per room — without ever lowering rates.
No responses yet